Pages

Saturday, November 21, 2026

Religious Freedom in India: Calls for Accountability and International Attention

Religious freedom is a fundamental human right recognised under international human rights principles. Every individual, regardless of religion, ethnicity or personal belief, should enjoy equal protection, dignity and freedom from discrimination. In a diverse country such as India, the protection of religious minorities is an important subject of public debate, constitutional responsibility and international human rights discussions.

Concerns raised by Gane Mills
Gane Mills, identified in the statement provided as a commissioner at the U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF), has expressed serious concerns about the alleged deportation of Indian citizens on the basis of their Muslim identity.

The statement argues that deporting people solely because they are Muslim would represent an alarming development in the treatment of religious minorities. It also calls upon the United States Department of State to consider designating India as a Country of Particular Concern (CPC) because of alleged ongoing, systematic and serious violations of religious freedom.

These remarks raise important questions about citizenship, religious identity, equal treatment and the responsibilities of governments towards their populations.

Religious freedom and constitutional principles
India's Constitution establishes important protections relating to equality and religious liberty.
Article 14 guarantees equality before the law and equal protection of the laws. Article 15 prohibits discrimination on specified grounds, including religion. Article 21 protects life and personal liberty, while Articles 25–28 establish important protections concerning freedom of religion.

These constitutional provisions provide a framework for examining allegations of discrimination, unequal treatment and restrictions on religious freedom.

Citizenship and religious identity are separate legal concepts. A person's religion, by itself, should not determine their citizenship rights or access to constitutional protections.

The deportation controversy
Allegations involving the deportation or removal of people identified as Muslims require careful examination. It is essential to distinguish between Indian citizens, foreign nationals, undocumented migrants and individuals whose citizenship is disputed.

The legal status of each person, the applicable legislation, the administrative procedure and the availability of judicial remedies are important considerations.

If Indian citizens are removed from the country solely because of their religious identity, such action would raise serious constitutional and human rights questions. However, allegations must be investigated through reliable documentation, individual case records and independent legal scrutiny.

USCIRF and the Country of Particular Concern designation
The United States Commission on International Religious Freedom is an independent, bipartisan federal commission established by the U.S. Congress. Its responsibility is to monitor religious freedom worldwide and make recommendations to the American government.

In its 2026 Annual Report, USCIRF recommended that India be designated a Country of Particular Concern. Its August 2026 country brief also described concerns involving discriminatory legislation, violence against religious minorities and restrictions affecting religious communities.
 
Under the International Religious Freedom Act of 1998, a CPC designation concerns governments responsible for, or tolerating, particularly severe violations of religious freedom. The designation is a decision for the U.S. government, not an automatic consequence of a USCIRF recommendation.
The distinction is important because USCIRF monitors conditions and recommends policy action, whereas the U.S. Department of State makes the official designation.

Electoral rolls, citizenship and minority rights
The controversy has also attracted attention because of India's nationwide electoral-roll revision. According to Reuters reporting published on November 19, 2026, approximately 130 million names were removed from voter lists during the exercise.

USCIRF expressed concern that Muslim citizens were being excluded and allegedly labelled foreigners, connecting the issue to broader concerns about deportation and religious discrimination.
India's Election Commission has maintained that the revision was intended to remove duplicate, deceased, relocated and otherwise ineligible voters. It has also stated that people removed incorrectly can pursue appeals.

An important legal distinction must be maintained: removal from an electoral roll does not, by itself, establish that an individual is a foreign national. Electoral eligibility and citizenship determination are separate legal questions.
 
International scrutiny and India's response
International human rights organisations, religious freedom advocates and policymakers have an important role in examining allegations of discrimination. Such scrutiny should be based on reliable evidence, transparent investigations and the protection of individual rights.

The Indian government has rejected USCIRF's criticism in previous responses, describing the commission as biased and its assessments as interference in India's internal affairs. This disagreement highlights the importance of examining primary documents, legal records and independently verified information rather than relying exclusively on political statements.
 
The importance of protecting every community
Religious freedom is not a privilege reserved for a majority community. It is a fundamental principle that applies equally to Muslims, Hindus, Christians, Sikhs, Buddhists, Jains and other religious communities.

A democratic society must ensure that citizenship, voting rights, personal security and access to justice are not determined by religious identity. Allegations of unlawful deportation, discrimination or exclusion deserve transparent investigation and appropriate legal remedies.
The international community should encourage dialogue, accountability and respect for constitutional safeguards. Governments should address legitimate security and immigration concerns through lawful procedures, individual assessments and judicial oversight.

Conclusion: Equality, dignity and justice
The concerns raised by USCIRF commissioner Gene Mills have brought renewed international attention to religious freedom in India. The call for a Country of Particular Concern designation reflects the commission's assessment of the seriousness of the reported violations.

Ultimately, the protection of religious minorities requires more than political statements. It requires equal treatment under the law, accountable institutions, independent investigations and meaningful protection of fundamental rights.

India's constitutional commitment to equality and religious liberty provides an important foundation for addressing these concerns. The credibility of any democracy depends not only on protecting the rights of its majority but also on ensuring that minorities can live with security, dignity and equal citizenship.

Religious freedom must remain a universal human right, protected without discrimination and upheld through justice, constitutional principles and the rule of law.