Pages

Tuesday, May 5, 2026

Shia or Sunni? Rethinking History of Pakistan’s Formation

Muhammad Ali Jinnah, widely known as Quaid-e-Azam, was the central political leader of the movement that led to the creation of Pakistan in 1947. His leadership was rooted not in sectarian identity but in constitutional politics, legal advocacy, and the idea of safeguarding the rights of Muslims as a political community in British India. Whether Jinnah personally identified as Shia or Sunni has been debated by historians, but what is clear is that he consistently avoided sectarian divisions in his public political life.

The creation of Pakistan was the result of a long political struggle involving millions of people from diverse backgrounds—Sunni, Shia, and other Muslim sects—as well as different ethnic and regional groups. Organizations like the All-India Muslim League played a crucial role in mobilizing support, and the idea of a separate homeland evolved over decades through political negotiations, elections, and mass movements. To attribute this historic achievement solely to one sect overlooks the contributions of countless individuals and communities.

The reference to Imam Hussain (a.s.) reflects the powerful symbolism of sacrifice, justice, and standing against  (oppression), values that resonate across many Muslim traditions—not just within Shia Islam. The legacy of Imam Hussain has inspired generations to stand for truth and justice, and these universal values can be seen in many political and social movements, including those in South Asia during the independence era.

It is also important to note that Muhammad Ali Jinnah himself envisioned a state where religion would not divide citizens. In his famous speech on August 11, 1947, he emphasized that people were free to practice their religion and that the state should treat all citizens equally, regardless of their faith or sect. This vision suggests that he aimed to build a nation beyond sectarian lines.

Statements that elevate one sect over another in the context of Pakistan’s creation risk deepening divisions rather than promoting unity. Pakistan’s history is shared by all its people, and its foundation rests on collective struggle, not exclusivity. Both Sunni and Shia Muslims, along with other communities, played vital roles in shaping the country.
In conclusion, while personal beliefs and historical inspirations matter, the creation of Pakistan cannot be credited to any single sect. It was a collective achievement driven by political leadership, mass participation, and a shared vision for a better future.